Part 36 exists to avoid enquiry into whether parties negotiated reasonably or not

13th February, 2017

In the case of Manna -v- Central Manchester Hospitals NHS Trust [2017] EWCA Civ 12 (view here) the Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge’s award of indemnity costs and refused to entertain a discussion as to whether the parties to the litigation had negotiated in a reasonable manner or not. Mrs Justice Cox said the Part 36 regime exists to prevent that very thing.


In contrast with the cases of Taylor -v- Honiton Town Counsel [2017] EWHC 101 (Admin) and Lloyds Bank -v- McBains Cooper [2017] EWHC 30 (TCC) where the courts had examined attempts at negotiation between the parties. Something to be discouraged after the Manna decision.


Attain are capable of handling all civil litigation costing work. Call us on 01664 565325 or visit